This is part two of a two part series on Victorian High Teas in and around Victoria, British Columbia.
So you’re in Victoria, British Columbia. You’re enjoying the sights of the fantastic Royal BC Museum and you’ve taken plenty of pictures of the famous Parliament Buildings at night. You’ve done some shopping, including buying some of those incredibly tasty Empress Creams at Roger’s Chocolates. And you’ve heard that your trip isn’t quite complete until you do high tea at the Empress Hotel.
Until you’ve seen the price of the tea.
You just can’t bring yourself to pay $50 for tea, can you? Feeling a little wallet shy?
Have you been to Butchart Gardens yet? No? Okay, good. Because here’s a way to get as good a quality tea in a beautiful setting for half the price of the Empress.
As I’ve said above, the Empress tea should not be missed. It’s an experience to take in. But yes, it is a little pricey and I know that the sticker shock can put some people off. For comparison research (oh, it was so difficult
, when I went up to Butchart Gardens to look at the amazing flower displays, I also did their tea and I can honestly say that it’s just as tasty as the Empress. And you’re only paying $25 per person.
Yes. That’s half the price of the Empress.
It’s still recommended that you make reservations. The good news, however, is that there is no dress code. I was walking around the gardens on a very wet and rainy day in my jeans and wasn’t turned back. If you forgot to make the reservation before you arrived at the Gardens, head over to the Guest Services desk and ask if they can make a reservation for you. Again, I would suggest taking tea for lunch, so eat a light breakfast and try to aim for as close to the lunch hour as possible for your reservation.
Butchart Garden’s afternoon tea takes place in The Dining Room Restaurant, once the home for the Butcharts, who began the gardens in 1905. The restaurant also serves a full menu for lunch and dinner, so if anyone else in your group decides to try the flame grilled Alberta bison burger or the seared wild BC salmon fillet “panzanella salad” while you take your afternoon tea, they are welcome to (although you will probably be taking up much of the table space. I’m sure you can reward the others at your table with a nibble of your shortbread cookie)
If possible, request the seats at the windows that overlook the Italian Garden so you can look at the gorgeous flowers that they’ve trained to climb up the walls of the restaurant and the bees that frequent them. It’s also a good vantage point to watch everyone coming and going through the garden.
The Dining Room Restaurant is a very quaintly decorated place, with flowery wallpaper, white linen on the tables and good service. The primary decorating focus is on the magnificent flower arrangements placed throughout the restaurant. This is, after all, one of the most visited flower gardens in North America. If your camera has gotten a workout through the gardens, it will no doubt get a little more exercise with the arrangements.
There are plenty of similarities between the Empress tea and the Gardens’ tea. There are multiple teas to choose from here, ranging from their own special Gardens Blend of Black tea blend of Darjeeling, Black Hunan and Gunpowder, to teas with hints of fruit and flowers, like the Teaberry Blend of black Ceylon tea flavored with strawberries, raspberries, blackberries and currants or the Rose Congou mix of Chinese black tea scented with rose petals, to the more recognizable standards of Earl Grey and English Breakfast, among others. I chose the Gardens Blend, figuring that again, I couldn’t go wrong with choosing the “official” tea. It was very rich without being overpowering and flavorful.
You won’t get as much guidance with how to take your tea here as you would at The Empress. But for some people, that may be a little more comforting, to not have someone telling you the way that you should drink tea. As I mentioned in part one though, try the tea in many different ways: with milk, without, with sugar, with milk and sugar, so you can get a feel for the range of flavor of your tea.
First course is a cup of seasonal fresh fruit with a delightfully sweet, but not too sweet, yogurt citrus dressing. The seasonal fruit included cubes of juicy cantaloupe and honeydew melons and chunks of fresh pineapple. It was nicely refreshing, especially with the freshly grated lemon and orange zest in the dressing.
Next came the three tiered serving platter that I’d become familiar with from The Empress. It was a somewhat similar layout, with the sandwiches and savories on the bottom, but the desserts were on the middle platter and the scones were on top. The other major change from The Empress’ tea display – Butchart serves warm savory pastries, such as a homemade sausage roll with imported mustard and a mini shrimp and Gruyere quiche.
I started with the warm savories, to be sure to enjoy them while they were still warm. The quiche was wonderful, with the right balance of Gruyere and buttery crust. I don’t tend to be a big fan of quiches, but this was very well done and just the right size. The homemade sausage roll was not the typical frozen roll you sometimes see at the grocery store. The sausage was definitely homemade and the portion ample. With it’s seasoning and the flaky pastry wrapped around it, I never needed the mustard at all.
Some of the sandwiches may sound familiar from The Empress, although many of them had a different twist to them that is unique to Butchart Gardens. The smoked salmon sandwich at Butchart, for instance, came with a maple Dijon cream cheese, which I wish were a little stronger. There was also egg salad, which was accompanied by watercress. The seasoning with this egg salad was more than The Empress’ version, and I found myself preferring the Butchart offering. The mango curry chicken salad was accompanied by toasted cashews and the cucumber salad was dressed with a fresh ginger cream cheese, which was light and favorable. One sandwich that Butchart served that The Empress did not as a smoked ham with sweet grainy mustard, which was very tasty. The smoked ham had the right amount of smokiness without being overpowering.
On to the scones. Butchart serves two warm scones, a traditional black currant scone and their signature candied ginger scone. Both are accompanied by strawberry jam and whipped Devon-style cream. My only complaint with the serving of the scones was that they were liberally dusted with powered sugar. I thought it unnecessary, as they didn’t really need the extra sweetening, not the mention my lap didn’t need the extra dusting of sugar either. Powdered sugar is pretty, but it’s also pretty messy. Other than that, the scones were very nice. Split open and swept with a dollop of strawberry jam and cream each, they were nicely moist and tasty.
Dessert was the star of the show, and rightfully so. It consisted of a fresh fruit tart, which was lightly painted with chocolate on the inside, a slice of housemade orange apricot loaf that provided a nice tartness to the dessert array, a lightly sweet and buttery shortbread cookie and, in my opinion, the best on the plate, a slice of chocolate brandy Napoleon cake. The cake was light and spongy, allowing the chocolate mousse layers to come to the forefront. I will admit that I did not try the Grand Marnier truffle, which I took home with me in it’s handy little box. It was also dusted with coconut, which I’m not fond of at all, but all reports from my husband were that it was very nice and definitely Grand Marnier.
At the end of tea, you are presented with a small box of loose tea to take home with you as a souvenir. And if you really enjoyed the tea you had, they are, of course, available for purchase at the gift shop. Forgot to take some home? They also sell some of their teas online.
I’m not going to say which tea was better, The Empress or Butchart Gardens. They are similar, but they are also different in many respects. Both are wonderful and both have excellent quality service and food. The main difference for me was the price and if the price is a major determining factor for you, then you don’t need to feel that you are missing out on the tea experience if you take tea at Butchart Gardens.

For a closer look at these and other pictures from Butchart Gardens, please click here.
Tips:
- Reservations for tea are recommended. During high travel season, plan to make your reservations at least two weeks in advance to avoid disappointment. If you are traveling during an off time, and you didn’t make reservations before coming to the Gardens, check in at the Guest Services desk and see if they can make the reservation for you.
- Enjoy the gardens first before taking tea, if your appetite can hold out. The tour loop through the gardens will take you to the restaurant at the end, so it’s a nice way to cap off your trip.
- Even if it’s not raining when you first arrive at the Gardens, take along one of their free umbrellas. Weather in British Columbia can change at the drop of a hat. Best to have it handy.
- Bring your camera and wear comfortable shoes.
Butchart Gardens
800 Benvenuto Avenue,
Brentwood Bay, BC V8M 1J8
1-866-652-4422 (toll free – general)
250-652-8222 (for tea reservations)